Close
Solutions
Resources

“HSAs are a great way to learn benefits and a great way to approach companies to develop confidence. They’re low cost, simple administratively, and you can learn them quickly.”

Read Case Study
Pricing
Careers
Search Site
Insights

What is the Element of Risk?

CRA requires HSAs to function like insurance, which means an 'element of risk' must exist — you can't set up a plan after an expense has already been incurred.

myHSA
Updated on:

The CRA guidelines for HSA's indicate that an HSA must act like a plan of insurance, and like insurance, there must exist an "Element of Risk". ​

So you know how you can't buy insurance after your house catches fire, or you can't buy health insurance after you have been diagnosed with an illness? The same exists for an HSA. ​

Here is where the "Element of Risk" really has to be taken into consideration:​​

Mid-Year Changes: — HSAs have rules about changing plan amounts in the middle of the year. This is because an HSA is based on predictions for the year's health needs. Changing it midway could raise red flags with the CRA. For this reason, generally, we recommend any plan limit changes be done at renewal.

There are circumstances where a plan increase can be mid-year but there are a few things to keep in mind:

Balance cannot be increased for just one employee, it must be increased for all employees in the class

If you are increasing the balance because an employee has incurred expenses greater than the plan limit set it could be seen as offside with the CRA to increase the limit mid-year

In any situation we always recommend you get the sign off of the corporate accountant

Reallocating Funds: — The CRA has set rules on when you can reallocate your funds, because that "Element of Risk" has to exist on a myFlex plan as well. You can't move funds between HSA and WSA freely, because you might have an event occur that you didn't plan for and reallocating the funds to accommodate that removes that "Element of Risk".

Backdating Plans: — You can't set up an HSA and backdate it to be effective prior to an even occuring. That would eliminate the "Element of Risk" that comes with having insurance, or an HSA in this case, to protect against future expenses. There are some situations where backdating is possible, download our guide to Backdating Guidelines below for all the details.

Backdating-Guidelines .pdf Download PDF • 36KB Danielle Constantine

CX Manager myHSA

Blog Highlights

Other Insights

Expert insights on flexible benefits, employee retention, and CRA-compliant plans in Canada.

Autumn leaves on a tree
Insights

September 2026 Advisor Newsletter

In this Issue: A year-end HSA checklist for clients & an advisor spotlight

Aly Edwards
Updated on:
Research

Why an HSA is the Best Small Business Benefits Package in Canada

Discover why Canadian small businesses are switching to Health Spending Accounts: 100% tax-deductible, flexible, and easier to manage than group insurance.

Aly Edwards
Updated on:
News

What is Multi-Factor Authentication, and Why is myHSA Using It?

What Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) is, why myHSA added it for Plan Administrators, and how to log in with your authenticator app.

Aly Edwards
Updated on:
Woman running by the ocean
Insights

Are Health and Fitness Apps Eligible Under an HSA in Canada?

Are health and fitness apps eligible under an HSA in Canada? The short answer? Generally, no. Read more to learn why.

Aly Edwards
Updated on:
Woman in glasses types on a laptop at a wooden desk in a cozy home office with shelves, plants, and a brick wall.
Insights

Why Choice is Becoming the Most Valuable Benefit You Can Offer

Why choice is becoming the most valuable benefit: myHSA's Danielle Constantine and Medcan's Sherri Look Yan on flexible benefits and preventative care.

Aly Edwards
Updated on:
Research

The 2025 myHSA Year-End Trend Report: A Closer Look into the World of Spending Accounts

2025 myHSA Trends Report cover on cream background with teal and black text; subtitle reads a closer look into the world of spending accounts.

Hailey Dirk
Updated on: